5 Comments
User's avatar
David Armstrong's avatar

Caryn, you make me think! Bonnie and I both like your explanation of the purpose of Jesus coming.

I have known for many years that your imagination goes far beyond my own. So I am sorry about your dog. At the same time, I remember my dogs from my childhood on the farm while not ever having thought of them having life after death.

Bonnie Zigterman's avatar

I love this. The shallow gospel that says "getting to heaven" is the whole purpose of Jesus coming and of faith has troubled me for a long time. No, Jesus came, to give us eternal life, and hallelujah for that, but also so that we could work with Him towards Shalom, to hasten the coming of the the New Heaven and New Earth, to work towards righteousness, to help in whatever ways we can to make this world the way it was meant to be. I once read an article about advent that said it wasn't just about the coming of Jesus, but the coming of the New Heaven and New Earth. They will know we are Christians by our love, by how we treat the least of these. I cannot write nearly as eloquently as you, but I think you hit the nail on the head. "The gospel [as a ticket to Heaven] suffers because it’s hollow. Shallow. Selfish. It’s transactional rather than transformational.....".

Melanie Springer Mock's avatar

This is so beautiful, Caryn. And such an important and incisive reflection on the rotten fruit of white evangelicalism. I'm so sorry about your dog; I love the image of Pigeon meeting the squirrels with whom Pigeon had once been enemies. I imagine many of will have similar encounters one day, shocked by who we will see on the other side.

Kate Bryant's avatar

You know I don’t align with you spiritually, but I do respect you and your views. You are one of the EXTREMELY FEW Christians I still call friends after walking away from the faith about 8-9 years ago. You reached out to me—not to chastise me or try to “draw me back to Jesus,” but to share my journey, because you love people and honor their unique journeys. I read your posts with reciprocal honor and respect. You’re a gem, my sister.

Im so sorry to hear about Pigeon, and I send you a warm hug.